This year the coveted Carnegie medal was won by the American author Jason Reynolds for his ten story-chapter novel, Look Both Ways. It is published by Knights Of with cover illustration by Selom Sunu.
Published by: Knights Of, 2019. Available from Amazon.
Some details about the 2021 winner Jason Reynolds and of the Carnegie Shadowers Award, Manjeet Mann, my review of Look Both Ways, and a brief history of the Carnegie medal.
This website contains affiliate links. If you buy items using these links, I receive a commission, at no extra cost to you.
About Jason Reynolds
Jason Reynolds, US National Ambassador for Children’s Literature, was born in 1983 in Washington D.C. As a child he loved rap and poetry. He has won many prestigious awards in America for his poetry collections, stories and novels and is the author of Miles Morales: Spiderman; the much loved and much quoted Run series of stories about Ghost, Patina, Sunny and Lu; Long Way Down and many other award-winning books.
Perhaps his most famous quote is from Ghost: “You can’t run away from who you are, but what you can do is run towards who you want to be.” This quote encouraging hope and endeavour is a rallying cry for all young people born in underprivileged and troubled backgrounds, the young people who feature in much of his writing.
In 2019 he wrote the verse novel that first brought him major recognition in Great Britain: Long Way Down.
‘Long Way Down’
Long Way Down is a free verse novel about street honour. A brief summary of the story is that fifteen year-old Will sees his brother shot and killed by a gang, and vows to ‘follow the rules’ and seek revenge. His descent to the street with gun in pocket is like a descent into hell: at each floor, the lift stops and the ghost of a dead person gets in and tells their story. The final person in the lift is Will’s dead brother, Shawn.
Long Way Down won many awards and accolades for Jason Reynolds and was shortlisted for the 2019 Carnegie Medal.
‘Look Both Ways’ – the 2021 Carnegie Medal winner
Jason wins the medal in 2021 for a very different book: his jazzy, funny, tender and child-centred novel, Look Both Ways.
In his Carnegie acceptance speech he said:
This book contains a lot but most importantly it’s just a fun story. I’m not interested in teaching anything, I’m only interested in bearing witness to the young people’s lives. And as long as young people continue to allow me to do so, I will continue to do so.
About ‘Look Both Ways’
There’s no doubt that the book is written for and about American children. The young British reader might struggle to understand the lifestyle and cultural references, but they’re on their own. There are no concessions to the non-American reader. They have to absorb it or ignore it, although for many British children, the American-ness will be hugely attractive.
My thoughts on ‘Look Both Ways’
I have to say that the first story in Look Both Ways left me cool. Too much bogey-chat (silly Uncle league), too uneventful, and I’m not fluent in street American. I recognised the underlayer of kids with problems just getting on with things, coping with life, but I wondered if the stories were going to be powerful enough to grip me and the child reader.
And then I read the second story, and I was completely won over. This little gang of kids, the Low Cuts, could break your heart. They need a whole book to themselves.
By the third story I was saying this man writes like a dream; poet, rapper, playing with words and ideas. He is master of the great American sentence, leaping and flying with language and images like a baseball player.
And so it continues. Look Both Ways is full of adorable characters and great moments. Each story is different, comical, sad, exuberant; the children and their street talk are carefully observed and splendidly portrayed, with tender and unspoken moments for the young reader to wonder at. These great, ordinary characters and their everyday, extraordinary moments are set against the alien and familiar world of their home streets and the dangerous background of school: “The hallway was a minefield, and there were hundreds of active mines dressed in T-shirts and jeans.”
You will love these kids. They are totally recognisable. You will love it when familiar characters crop up, or drift by, but they’ve had their turn, and new characters have stepped forward. By now you’re eager to hear their story. Perhaps my favourite character is Simeon carrying little Kenzi on his back. Perhaps it’s Stevie, who never gets it right. Or sad little Fatima Moss with her endless lists and notes. Perhaps it’s Pia Foster, the fierce skateboarder of Skitter Hitter.
Actually my favourite character of all is Satchmo, and my favourite story is Satchmo’s Master Plan – a boy versus a dog. It’s even better that any Scaredy Squirrel story – can you believe that? I won’t spoil Satchmo’s wonderful story by telling you any more – but I defy you to finish it without tears in your eyes!
I’m not saying that Look Both Ways is an easy read. Not all the stories have the same weight or interest, and might be baffling for younger readers. Jason Reynolds’ wild and wonderful style, playful and ambitious, will task some readers, though others will rejoice in it and enjoy trying to imitate it. For example, I’m thinking of the story called Ookabooka Land. The central character, Cynthia, is a joker, like her granddad, the class clown, and the despair and delight of her teacher. Her stories are free-flowing and almost inpenetrable. “I don’t know what’s going on?” I can hear the reader saying. Just go with it. Enjoy it.
Look Both Ways is an exhilarating read. One thing is for sure; you and your child will never have read anything like it!
A child’s review of ‘Look Both Ways’
Children’s books are of course intended for children to read, so here’s a review from nine-year-old Eda, known to her family as Eda the Reader:
I didn’t think the cover was exciting enough, but I like the book. I didn’t really notice it was American except they use words like dollar. It could have been anywhere. I like the characters and their personalities, and the way you go from one story to another, with different people, which makes it interesting. My favourite story was The Low Cuts Strikes Again, because the kids are funny. They steal money but only loose change. I would recommend Look Both Ways for anyone between nine and fifteen. I had never heard of Jason Reynolds before but I might read something else by him.
The 2021 Carnegie Shadowers Award
The CILIP Carnegie & Kate Greenaway Shadowing Scheme brings thousands of young people in schools and public libraries together to discuss the shortlisted titles and choose their own favourite book. The 2021 Carnegie Shadowers award goes to Run Rebel, by playwright, producer and novelist Manjeet Mann.
Run Rebel is a “trailblazing verse novel that thunders with rhythm, heart and soul”. Published by Penguin Random House.
Published by Penguin Random House. Available from Amazon.
About the Carnegie Medal
The Carnegie Medal is named after Andrew Carnegie, a Scottish-American philanthropist who established over 2,800 libraries in the English-speaking world. He died in 1919, and in 1936 the British Library Association established the Carnegie Medal to celebrate the centenary of his birth. The award was to be given annually to the author of the most outstanding book for children and young adults written in the English language.
The first Carnegie medal was won by Arthur Ransome for Pigeon Post. Since then it been awarded 82 times and eight authors have won it twice. It is administered by CILIP (Chartered Institute of Library and Information Professionals) and described by them as the oldest and most prestigious award for children’s literature.
Its sister award is the Kate Greenaway Medal, awarded for the best illustration of a children’s book published in English in the UK. See also my review of the 2021 Greenaway winner, Small in the City by Sydney Smith.
My own Carnegie books
Two of my own books, Granny was a Buffer Girl (1986) and Dear Nobody (1991) were Carnegie medal winners, so I know well how utterly thrilled Jason Reynolds will be with this award. My sincere congratulations go to him and to Manjeet Mann for their outstanding achievements. I can well imagine their great joy and wish them every success with their novels.
Granny was a Buffer Girl: This is a collecion of linked short stories about three generations of a working-class family, set in Sheffield between 1930 and 1980. Each of the main characters featured in the stories is a teenager.
Dear Nobody: Set in Sheffield in the 1980s, Dear Nobody is a two-narrator young adults’ novel telling the story of Helen (17) and Chris (18). They think they know what their future plans are, until Helen discovers she is pregnant.
In 1994, Willa and Old Miss Annie was Highly Commended.
Children are asked to write short stories all the time at school. Can you recommend any other collections or individual stories to inspire them? For instance, many years ago I read Doris Lessing’s Through the Tunnel, and I’ve never forgotten it.
You can follow me on Twitter .